Plaintiff Midwest Athletics and Sports Alliance LLC (“MASA”) filed a patent infringement action against Ricoh USA, Inc. (“Ricoh”) alleging infringement of certain printing-related patents. Ricoh sought production of certain categories of documents that MASA contended were privileged and, therefore, not subject to disclosure. Ricoh contended that the documents are responsive…
Articles Posted by Stan Gibson
Webinar on October 20, 2020: When Artificial Intelligence is the inventor, who owns the patent?
Upcoming webinar: When Artificial Intelligence is the inventor, who owns the patent? Join us for a one-hour webinar on the topic, “When AI is the inventor, who owns the patent?” Register now. Who Should Attend: General Counsel, Patent Counsel Date: Tuesday, October 20, 2020 Time: 11 AM – 12 PM…
VirnetX v. Apple: Delay of Five Months Justifies Denial of Motion to Amend Judgment of More Than $400 Million
In this long running patent dispute, the district court denied Apple’s motion to amend the judgment based on a five month delay. The district court explained the long running history of the case as follows: “Nearly 10 years ago, VirnetX sued Apple, alleging Apple’s FaceTime and VPN on Demand features…
Privilege Waived Where Attorney Allowed Questioning Over Privileged Document During Remote Deposition
In this patent infringement action, the plaintiff’s counsel deposed one of the defendant’s (DJO) Fed.R.Evid. 30(b)(6) witnesses during a deposition that took place remotely. At the remote deposition, counsel questioned the witness regarding a license agreement and a privileged letter that was apparently appended to the license agreement. Plaintiff then…
District Court Excludes Damage Opinion That Used Cost Savings Approach and That Resulted in Ignoring The Smallest Salable Component
In this patent infringement action, Microchip accused Aptiv’s Dual Role Hub of infringing several the patents. As the district court explained, the Dual Role Hub is a media module that Aptiv manufactures and sells to automakers for incorporation into a car’s infotainment system through USB peripherals, such as a smart…
Alleged Bias Not a Sufficient Basis to Exclude Expert on Invalidity and Infringement
In this patent infringement action, the plaintiffs sought to exclude the defendant’s expert on invalidity and infringement. One of the grounds on which they sought to exclude the testimony was based on bias. The plaintiffs contended that the expert’s bias stemmed from his belief that he invented certain of the…
Deepfakes: Dangers and Developments in California
In the article, “Deepfakes: new California laws address dangers and development”, published by the Daily Journal, author Stan Gibson address two new California laws that have been enacted to combat the risk of “deepfake” videos. Deepfake videos, in which a person in an existing image or video is replaced with…
Granting Security Interest in Patents Did Not Deprive Patent Owner of Standing to Sue for Patent Infringement
Raffel Systems, LLC (“Raffel”) filed a patent infringement action against Man Wah Holdings (“Man Wah”). Man Wah moved to dismiss the patent claims on the ground that Raffel did not possess title to the patents at the time the lawsuit was filed and therefore lacked standing to sue. As explained…
District Court Denies Production of Documents Pertaining to Litigation Funding
In this patent infringement action, AT&T filed a motion to compel certain litigation-funding discovery from the plaintiff, United Access Technologies, LLC (“UAT”). The district court reviewed documents relating to or from third parties regarding potential investments by those third parties in UAT’s lawsuits and communications to and from third parties…
District Court Adopts Recommendation of Special Master Awarding Reasonable Attorney’s Fees Based on Flat Fee Agreement
Following Straight Path IP Group’s, the patent owner’s, unsuccessful appeal, Apple and Cisco moved for reasonable attorney’s fees. Although the district court reaffirmed the exceptionality of the patent owner’s prosecution of the case, the district court found that defendants’ fee requests were too high and directed the parties to submit…